When $180 Million Rides on an Expert's Supplementation Decision
$180M oil case lost when Apollo refused to fix expert's flawed damages model. Without expert testimony meant no damages recovery in technical fields.
CaseUpdate86
Check out the latest posts
Tackling Free-Use and At-The-Well Royalties
Lease royalty calculated on “market value at the well” held to bear a proportion of gas used off the lease premises as a form of post-production cost under the workback method...
When "Imprudent" Becomes Irrelevant: How Express JOA Language Overrides Operator Discretion
Texas Crude and Warwick sued Burlington after it refused to drill 44 proposed wells, claiming it would be "imprudent." Court ruled operator must drill when all parties consent.
"Void" Means Void: How Missing Consent Toppled a $2.5 Million Pipeline Judgment
Texas court: Pipeline assignment without written consent was 'void,' destroying entire chain of title and $2.5M judgment. One broken link meant all downstream transfers fail.
Who Can Enforce Surface Provisions in an OGL?
Mineral owners are often subject to general oil and gas lease forms that include provisions benefitting the surface estate. But, when they own no interest in the surface, who, if anyone, has the right to enforce those provisions?
When Does a Fixed NPRI Become Floating?
The Texas Supreme Court ruled that ratifying a lease doesn't change a fixed NPRI to a floating one. However, a subsequent stipulation between parties can modify the NPRI, rejecting the argument that an unambiguous deed cannot be altered by a later stipulation.